Morning Edition · №
Justice NEW YORK

Forensic Pathologist Tells BBC Newsnight Evidence Points to Epstein Being Strangled, Not Suicide

Professor Michael Freeman's non-peer-reviewed analysis of autopsy photos challenges the 2019 medical examiner's finding, though officials say they stand by the suicide ruling.

Forensic Pathologist Tells BBC Newsnight Evidence Points to Epstein Being Strangled, Not Suicide
— Photograph: Katrin Bolovtsova / Pexels
SHARE X f in ⧉

A forensic pathologist who has served as a cause-of-death expert for U.S. attorneys general, including in deaths in police custody such as George Floyd's, said this week that his review of autopsy materials leads him to believe Jeffrey Epstein was killed, challenging the official 2019 finding that the financier and convicted sex offender died by suicide in his Manhattan jail cell.

Professor Michael Freeman told BBC Newsnight that after reviewing the New York City medical examiner's file he believes Epstein was strangled, "most likely from behind." He pointed to what he described as a deep hemorrhage to Epstein's left shoulder, facial injuries he said were consistent with being struck, and fingernail marks above the ligature mark on Epstein's neck that he said were "consistent with strangulation, particularly from behind, and the attempt by the victim to try to remove the ligature from the neck." Freeman, who had previously signaled he would present evidence on both sides of the question, delivered his findings publicly at a University College London lecture on Monday evening and said he has since published his research alongside the medical examiner's files.

Freeman did not examine Epstein's body himself. He worked from case files and photographs supplied by Epstein's brother, Mark Epstein, who has long maintained his brother was murdered, though Freeman said his analysis was conducted independently and that he was not paid for it. His findings have not been peer-reviewed.

The official finding stands, for now

The medical examiner who performed the original autopsy told the Justice Department's internal watchdog that Epstein's injuries were more consistent with a suicide by hanging than a homicide by strangulation, and noted the absence of defensive wounds typically seen in strangulation victims. Dr. Barbara Sampson, the city's chief medical examiner at the time, has previously said she "stand[s] firmly behind" the finding. A 2023 inspector general report into Epstein's custody found no evidence contradicting the hanging-and-suicide finding, though it identified serious negligence and falsified records by jail staff who were supposed to be checking on him.

Asked who might have killed Epstein if his reading of the evidence is correct, Freeman said he had "no idea" and that the question was outside the scope of his analysis. Pressed on whether his conclusions veered into conspiracy theory, he said: "I have the luxury of being able to say, don't take my word for it, let everybody look at it... If you think I'm still a conspiracy theorist because I'm looking at something that looks like a strangulation and say I think it is a strangulation and I don't think it could be a hanging, show me where I got it wrong."

Epstein was awaiting trial on sex-trafficking charges when he was found dead at the Metropolitan Correctional Center on Aug. 10, 2019. The new claim is likely to intensify pressure on the Justice Department, which has faced sustained public skepticism over its handling of Epstein-related records, though officials have given no indication the manner-of-death finding will be reopened.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE X Facebook LinkedIn Copy link
Dana Whitfield · U.S. Correspondent

Reports the American story for UBStandard — infrastructure, weather, communities and the forces reshaping daily life across the U.S.

[email protected]
Related coverage Front page →