Morning Edition · №
SALT LAKE CITY

DNA Testing Links Ted Bundy to a Utah Teenager's Murder, 52 Years Later

Investigators say new forensic technology confirmed Bundy killed Melissa Anne Smith in 1974 — and that his full toll in Utah still isn't closed.

DNA Testing Links Ted Bundy to a Utah Teenager's Murder, 52 Years Later
Big Cottonwood Canyon in Utah's Wasatch Mountains — illustrative, not the actual case site. — Photograph: Alex Moliski / Unsplash
SHARE X f in ⧉

Utah investigators say new DNA testing has confirmed that Ted Bundy murdered 17-year-old Melissa Anne Smith, closing the book on a Utah cold case that sat unsolved for 52 years. Smith vanished from Midvale in October 1974 and her body was found by a hunter weeks later; the announcement lands almost exactly a half-century after that discovery.

A match decades in the making

Investigators compared a Y-STR genetic profile recovered from evidence in Smith's case against the profile already tied to Bundy through his confirmed killing of another Utah teenager, 17-year-old Laura Ann Aime, a case the same lab linked to Bundy earlier this year. The breakthrough was made possible by newer forensic technology the Utah state crime lab acquired in 2023, which can extract usable DNA from samples that are small, degraded by age, or mixed with DNA from more than one person — the kind of evidence that would have been unworkable with the technology available when Smith disappeared, according to KUTV's reporting on the lab's findings.

Aime disappeared from a Halloween party and was found a month later along a highway in American Fork Canyon; Smith was last seen after leaving a drugstore where she worked. Both cases fit the broader pattern of young women abducted in Utah during the mid-1970s that has long been attributed to Bundy, who was executed in Florida in 1989 after confessing to dozens of murders across several states without ever fully accounting for his victims.

Still an open file

Detective Ben Pender, who has worked the cold-case unit pursuing Bundy's Utah victims, said confirming the Smith case "does not close the book on Ted Bundy," according to CTV News's account of the announcement. Investigators say they are now focused on the unsolved 1974 death of 16-year-old Nancy Wilcox, another presumed Bundy victim, and have said evidence points toward him in that case without yet being conclusive.

The identifications give two families long-delayed certainty about how their daughters died, even as they underline how much of Bundy's full toll may never be fully documented. Utah's crime lab has said it intends to keep retesting evidence from the era's unsolved disappearances as forensic technology continues to improve, meaning further announcements tied to Bundy or other serial offenders from the period remain possible.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE X Facebook LinkedIn Copy link
Dana Whitfield · U.S. Correspondent

Reports the American story for UBStandard — infrastructure, weather, communities and the forces reshaping daily life across the U.S.

[email protected]
Related coverage Front page →