Older adults who nap longer, more often, or mostly in the morning face a higher risk of dying over the following years than those who take short, occasional, afternoon naps, according to a study that tracked more than 1,300 seniors for up to 19 years using wrist-worn activity monitors rather than self-reported sleep diaries.
The research, led by Chenlu Gao of Mass General Brigham along with colleagues at Rush University Medical Center, drew on participants in the long-running Rush Memory and Aging Project, a cohort study of older adults in northern Illinois that began in 1997. Starting in 2005, 1,338 participants wore activity monitors for about ten days, giving researchers objective data on how long, how often, and when they napped, which the team then compared against mortality records collected over the following years.
The associations were notable in size. Each additional hour of daily napping was linked to roughly 13 percent higher mortality risk, and each additional nap per day to about 7 percent higher risk, according to the Mass General Brigham announcement of the findings, published in JAMA Network Open. Morning nappers had about 30 percent higher mortality risk than those who napped in the early afternoon. Notably, irregular napping patterns from day to day showed no link to higher mortality, and the researchers say naps totaling under an hour a day are "most likely benign."
It is important to note that this is correlation, not causation.
Chenlu Gao, study lead author, Mass General Brigham
Gao and her coauthors are careful to frame napping as a potential warning sign rather than a danger in itself. "Excessive napping is likely indicating underlying disease, chronic conditions, sleep disturbances, or circadian dysregulation," Gao said, rather than napping itself shortening lives. Coauthor Aron Buchman, a neurologist at Rush, suggested the pattern could have practical use for families: "Excessive naps and naps that occur in the morning could mean something more serious is happening with their health," he said, adding that caregivers who notice a change in a loved one's napping might want to have them checked out.
The study has real limits that the authors themselves flag. It is observational, so it cannot show that napping habits caused earlier deaths, only that the two were associated after statistical adjustment. The Rush cohort is mostly white and drawn from a single region, limiting how far the findings generalize, and napping was measured only once, near the start of each participant's involvement, so any changes in napping habits over the ensuing years aren't captured. The work was funded chiefly by the National Institutes of Health, the Alzheimer's Association, the American Academy of Sleep Medicine Foundation and the BrightFocus Foundation; the funders, the researchers say, had no role in the study's design or conclusions.