Mayor Zohran Mamdani unveiled a plan Friday to close New York City's Rikers Island jail complex by 2032, proposing four smaller borough-based jails and a sharp reduction in the number of people held in detention. The plan, laid out in an 88-page report, would replace the 413-acre island facility between Queens and the Bronx, which Mamdani said was built on "deteriorating infrastructure" and which officials have a "moral imperative" to close.
A deadline the city has already missed once
New York's city council first voted to close Rikers Island, long nicknamed "Gladiator School" for its dilapidated, violent conditions, back in 2019, setting a legal deadline of 2027. That timeline slipped amid disputes over where to relocate the jail's population and, Mamdani's office said, pandemic-era delays and inaction under former Mayor Eric Adams. A federal judge removed Rikers from the city's direct control last year under Adams, appointing an independent official to oversee it after staffing shortages, crumbling conditions and a string of inmate deaths — nine so far this year alone.
Under the new plan, the city would open a jail in Brooklyn by 2029, one each in the Bronx and Queens by 2031, and one in Manhattan by 2032, while reducing the daily detainee population from roughly 6,500 to a target of about 4,100. Mamdani's office argues the smaller, borough-based sites would give detainees "access to daylight, fresh air and clean space" and cut travel times for families, who can currently spend hours reaching the remote island. The plan pairs the new jails with $146 million for mental health and substance-use treatment and vocational and education programming, along with hundreds of new therapeutic beds for detainees with serious mental illness — building on 100 such beds the administration has already opened at Bellevue Hospital.
Dana Kaplan, the administration's "Close Rikers Czar," told the BBC the proposal was a "generational opportunity" to rethink how the city detains people, not simply a plan to tear down an old facility. Mamdani also pledged to shrink the jail population further through alternatives to pretrial detention, easier online bail payments and a faster pretrial court process.
Officers' union calls the population target reckless
The city's correction officers' union rejected the population cap outright. "[B]uilding a new system that puts an arbitrary cap on the City's available jail beds is ill-conceived, irresponsible and jeopardizes the safety of all New Yorkers, including our Officers," the Correction Officers' Benevolent Association said in a statement, arguing the city could not hold the line at 4,100 beds "without irresponsibly releasing individuals who committed violent felony charges." Kaplan disputed that framing. "It's actually possible to have fewer people in jail in New York City — and that is what we should be planning for," she said.
The New York City Council must still approve the updated closure timeline, though council members, including the speaker, have signaled support. If the plan holds, Rikers — which has held high-profile detainees from Tupac Shakur to Harvey Weinstein over the decades — would close for good six years from now, nearly a decade after the city first promised to shut it down.