Morning Edition · №
Nutrition TORONTO

A Small Trial Challenges Decades of Advice to Skip Full-Fat Dairy

Adults with overweight or obesity who ate three servings of whole milk, cheese or yogurt a day for 12 weeks showed no worse weight, cholesterol or blood pressure than those who mostly avoided dairy — reviving debate over whether "low-fat" was ever the right advice.

A Small Trial Challenges Decades of Advice to Skip Full-Fat Dairy
Whole milk poured into a glass — illustrative, not from the study itself. — Photograph: Eiliv Aceron / Unsplash
SHARE X f in ⧉

For decades, dietary guidelines have steered people toward low-fat dairy on the assumption that the saturated fat in whole milk, full-fat yogurt and regular cheese works against a healthy weight and heart. A small randomized trial out of the University of Toronto, getting fresh attention this month after its initial publication earlier this year, suggests that assumption deserves a second look.

Researchers led by Harvey Anderson, a professor of nutritional sciences at the university's Temerty Faculty of Medicine, split 74 adults with overweight or obesity into three groups for 12 weeks. One group ate little dairy on a calorie-restricted diet; the other two ate three daily servings of full-fat dairy, provided by the researchers, on different calorie plans. All participants otherwise followed guidance based on Canada's official food guide.

Compared with the low-dairy group, the study, published in The Journal of Nutrition, found no meaningful differences in weight gain, body composition or blood cholesterol among participants eating three servings of full-fat dairy a day. "Importantly, [the higher-dairy groups] didn't have adverse levels of blood cholesterol or lipids," Anderson said, adding that the groups also showed no sign of worsening insulin resistance. The dairy-eating groups saw improvements in blood pressure and ate more calcium, protein and vitamin D than the low-dairy group.

Anderson attributes the findings to what nutrition researchers call the "dairy matrix" — the idea that how nutrients are packaged inside a food, not just their raw fat or calorie content, shapes how the body processes them. In milk and cheese, he noted, "two proteins — casein and whey — that are bound together with fat" may blunt the metabolic effects that fat alone would have eaten in isolation.

The study has real limits: it was small, lasted only three months, and was funded in part by Canada's dairy industry through the Dairy Research Cluster program, a detail worth weighing against its conclusions. Anderson himself cautioned that longer, larger trials are needed before anyone can say full-fat dairy prevents or worsens heart disease or diabetes over a lifetime — and he stopped well short of telling people to abandon low-fat dairy altogether. "Keep it simple, eat a variety of foods and not too much of anything," he said.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE X Facebook LinkedIn Copy link
Samuel Okafor · Health & Medicine Correspondent

Covers health and medicine for UBStandard: drug approvals, clinical research and the systems that deliver care.

[email protected]
Related coverage Front page →